Contact Us Now
  • Home
  • About Us
    • About Jennifer
    • Our Team
    • Testimonials
  • Work
  • Learn
  • Visit
  • News
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • 2022-2023 Charity – Grand River Hospital Foundation

When Facing Criminal-Like Charges, Be Aware

by Administrator | Nov 11, 2015 | Kitchener Immigration Lawyer, News, Trouble

Sentencing

Sentencing and conditionalA conditional sentence (such as house arrest) is available when the accused may show circumstances for the court to be lenient. However; in the immigration context, such leniency does not reflect the same way, because immigration presumes that convicted permanent residents or foreign Nationals already pleaded for any immigration consideration at sentencing.   That’s how federal court stated in “Tran” on Oct 30, 2015.

As a result, it is critical to engage an immigration professional early-on when permanent residents or foreign Nationals face any criminal or criminal-like charges (drug charges).

Background

Some of you may be aware of this decision: FCA (Federal Court of Appeal) allowed Tran (2014 FC1040), issued recently, but I want to share it with you in context of criminal law & immigration law.

Mr. Tran was charged and convicted of production of a controlled substance – s.7(1) of CDSA in January 2013. At such time, the max term was 7 years for this conviction. But, Nov. 6, 2012 prior to Jan/2013, it was changed to 14 years from 7 years. He ended up getting a conditional sentence of imprisonment of 12 months in the end.

Mr. Tran won this conditional sentence because (1) his max sentence of imprisonment was 7 years, not 10 years; (2) “term of imprisonment” under s. 36(1)(a) [criminal inadmissibility] or s.64(2) [PR criminality] was only for “carceral term of imprisonment” to exclude a “conditional term of imprisonment”.

The Federal Court of Appeal now allowed the government’s appeal based on the following two points:

1. a conditional sentence of imprisonment (s.742 to s.742.7 of CCC) is now reasonably interpreted as “imprisonment” under Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (s.36(1)(a)); and

2. the phrase “punishable by a maximum term of imprisonment of at least 10 years” under s.36(1)(a) of IRPA can reasonably be interpreted as the maximum term of imprisonment under the law in force at the time admissibility is determined, NOT at the time of sentencing.

We find the second point more troublesome for any criminal lawyers, since one may not consider it a problem at the time of sentencing, but it could be a problem at any time until/if Canada Border Services Agency triggers its intention to carry out any admissibility determination.

Any permanent resident who has a brush with the law– drink & driving, assaults, etc. would be exposed. Simply put, conditional sentencing did not used to affect permanent residents’ removal from Canada, but now it does!

This would remove permanent residents with conditional sentence from Canada without any benefits of appeal to Immigration Appeal Division where they could bring humanitarian and compassionate grounds for re-consideration.

 

If you have any individual questions or concerns, please contact our office for more customized consultation for your unique situation. Please note that this posting is for general information only and is not to be considered binding or official legal counsel since situations will vary and can be complicated. The content in this post is current as of the day of entry. Due to the changing nature of Immigration law, the information in this entry may or may not still be applicable.

Looking For Something?

Use the form below to search the site:

Still not finding what you’re looking for?

Drop us a note so we can take care of it!

News

Amazing News for Ontario Employers, Foreign Workers & International Students!

Mar 20, 2023

Ontario is set to double the number of economic immigrants it welcomes to the province under an agreement with the federal government to boost the Ontario Immigrant Nominee Program. In an announcement, Saturday, Ontario Labour and Immigration Minister Monte McNaughton...

Application and Deadlines Update – March 2023

Mar 20, 2023

With the fully online system as of the end of September 2022, there are more applications in the system, which may end up using more AI decision programming by IRCC to facilitate such volume. Then, it leads to court cases where applicants either ask for processing...

Draw: 7,000 Invitations with 490 Points Cut Off

Mar 20, 2023

All program selections for 7,000 invitations with 490 points cut-off! Read more: https://www.canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/services/immigrate-canada/express-entry/submit-profile/rounds-invitations.html

Our Clients

An excellent experience! Jennifer was so quick to respond and made me feel valued. It was obvious she loves her work and does it with a smile. Her priority is clearly to help people.

Read More Testimonials

  • Follow
  • Follow
  • Follow
  • Follow
  • Follow

Jennifer Roggemann Law Office 1135 King Street East, Kitchener, Ontario, N2G 2N3 Phone: 519-744-3570 Fax: 519-744-3571 ©2022. All Rights Reserved.